sixtyminutes blog

Liam Bartlett: The West Bank

, Prev Next

Trying to understand the Middle East peace process is a bit like attempting to unscramble an egg so we travelled to Israel to get a first-hand look at just how hard it might be to even begin a so-called 'road map to peace'.

At the very heart of the problem are the Jewish settlers, now occupying large tracts of land that the Palestinians say are really theirs. The settlers are essentially squatting on whatever piece they choose and constructing houses and towns in a defiant gesture of "now that I'm here – it's all mine".

Nowhere was this sentiment more strongly expressed than at a settlement on the eastern fringe of the West Bank, south of Jerusalem, when Nadia Matar told me that her people had: "Inherited the land from God and they were not going anywhere".

Nadia is one of the founding members of the "Women in Green" movement, which is dedicated to supporting Israel's military and has pledged to never give back an inch of territory to the Palestinians. At best, they will let them live in Israel but without the right to vote. Indeed, Nadia told me she didn't really care where any of the Palestinians decided to live as they had: "Over 20 Arab states to choose from so they can go to any one of them".

Nadia's extremism was repeated tenfold by many of the settlers we spoke to and especially through the video footage we saw from a group called B'Tselem. This unique human rights organisation has started a project that was originally dubbed the "Shooting back campaign". As the name suggests, they armed dozens of Palestinians, not with guns but with video cameras and taught them how to 'shoot' when they were on the receiving end of any conflict with Jewish settlers. The result is that the rest of the world, through programmes like ours, can now begin to see that perhaps the violence and confrontations are not as one-sided as the Israeli's would have us believe.

Certainly, there are still deadly rocket attacks from extremist Arab groups and the seriousness of these should in no way be downplayed but when you witness up close how the average Palestinian is controlled, it puts that violence into perspective.

The case of Palestinian Doctor Mustafa Barghouthi is a prime example. A trained doctor and also an independent member of the Palestinian Parliament, Dr Barghouthi was born and raised in Jerusalem and worked in a local hospital for 14 years. Despite now working only 30 minutes away in nearby Ramullah, he is never allowed to return to his town of birth. His sister is there, his friends and former work colleagues, but he is prevented from ever going back. The Israeli's deny him access through any one of hundreds of checkpoints. I asked him if they suspected him of being a terrorist, even though he is blatantly independent of either Hamas or Fatah. He said: "Well, they never said so, but I think it's one way of oppressing me from telling the truth."

Nowhere is the upheaval these settlers are causing more obvious than in the West Bank city of Hebron. There, the Israeli government has allowed settlers to live smack, bang in the middle of a Palestinian town and, in so doing, has turned a once thriving shopping precinct into a virtual ghost town. Its streets are now strewn with weeds, all the shop fronts are boarded up, and the dusty footpaths are constantly patrolled by Israeli soldiers, stationed there to protect the settlers.

Overall, it's an extremely sad part of the world, especially when you are visiting from such a blessed country as Australia. The constant animosity is incredibly depressing to observe. In some parts, the argument has become something of a blood sport. At one Palestinian village, Nilim, just north of Ramullah, the local youths protest every Friday at the fence of the adjoining settlement. And like clockwork, the Israeli police and military turn up and fire tear gas at them. Sometimes it escalates, sometimes not, but I can tell you, being on the receiving end of that gas is not a comfortable thing. It snaps your eyes shut, stings your skin and leaves a nauseating taste in the mouth.

That said, it's preferable to rubber bullets and that's always a possibility, too. This is the third time I've covered a story in Israel and whilst it never gets any easier, it is such a key plank to wider world peace, that you have to remain optimistic that things can change for the better.

User comments
About a couple of weeks ago I forwarded a few legit messages, but none were posted. I thought you closed the mail box. However, you were waiting long enough to get clossure posting number 306 after supposedly from a Jewish person. Incredible. Unbelievable. What a pot of Bull Dust. I lived in Israel for 7 years. My whole family lives in Israel as well as many friends I left behind when I followed my Australian husband. This is so untrue. I remember the 1973 war and the continious terror and arrogance of our so-called poor neghbours. Some comments here would make every moral person sick.
As a Jew myself, this does'nt surprise me, i have visited the Middle East many times and saw this sickening behaviour unfold in front of me, the Israeli's in the Isreal think they own all the land of palestine and can destroy whatever they want. -- Thanks Liam Barlett for a Courages story!
It puzzles me that pro Israeli posts are so pre-occupied with who got hit with which stone,rock,the shape, or they get rocketed by Quassam rockets, which have a massive 10kg warhead made predominantly out of agricultural fertiliser). No! Like most things in life.... it's not about the facts (because we all know they are only selectively presented ). It's about perception and the perception is that the zionist entity is hell bent on a slow motion ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian homeland. That has become patently clear to the most switched off sports loving, shopping addicted, fast food munching voter. Therefore no amount of hand wringing, and university educated spokespeople waxing about the righteousness of their cause, with of course carefully inserted references to the holocaust and when all that fails shouts of anti-semitism will erase that now mainstream accepted viewpoint. When will the world will realise that this land is too important and put it under UN mandated control?
Hey Liam, My problem with your reporting is that you try to "unscramble" a 60-year old issue by only looking at the here and now. For instance, you view the settlements as the sole problem of the Middle East conflict, when Israel has repeatedly stated its willingness to give the Palestinians (Yassir Arafat, to be exact) huge tracts of land within Israel in the ongoing "land-for-peace" negotiations. What you do, Liam, is the equivalent of analyzing the fallacies of a war before understanding the reasons behind that war. It is extremely short-sighted and dishonest as a reporter. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and call you misinformed, but in terms of the conflict being based on land (i.e. settlements), you only have to look at Gaza - 3 years ago - to understand that isn't the case. In short, Israel pulled out of Gaza, gave it to the Palestinians, and received only rocket-fire and hatred in return. If the issue was land, by logic, they should have received peace.
A 50-year-old woman was seriously wounded on Friday afternoon on 9 October, 2009 after rocks were hurled at the car she was traveling inortheast ofRamallah. A man, lightly injured during the attack, was treated by MagenDavid Adom paramedics. The two were traveling when assailants threw rocks towards the car, piercing the windshield. The man continueddriving until they reached Samaria's Tapuah Junction where he alertedrescue forces. Both the man and woman were evacuated to BeilinsonHospital in Petah Tikva. Medical officials said the woman was suffering from a fractured skull. HERE it says how peaceful rock throwing crowds are. Make your own conclusions before judging.
Rocks are deadly weapons. In New Jersey the police ruled that children or adults who threw rocks at passing motorists were guilty of attempted murder. Lethal fire should be used to stop attempted murder.
Thank you sixty minutes for reminding Australia and the world about whats really happening. Would love to see more of this reporting- that potrays whats happening from the Palestinian side, a truthful and real coverage. With more reports like these there would be more understanding, less bias and hatred towards one another.
Thank you 60 minuets. What a sad mess the Israelis have made of the country, the arrogance of the settlers had to be seen to be believed.
Thank you Liam and 60 minutes for showing the injustice that Palestinians had been living with for the last 40 years. Thanks for your courage to show the truth. Roads for Jews only, this in a state that described by the west as the beacon of democracy. What a joke. As for the anti-Palestinians (or we can call them ant-justice or anti-human rights) they have the audacity to defend the crimes of their beloved Terrorist apartheid state against humanity. May be they will have no problem having roads for Whites only someday in Australia.
we will never get the truth of whats really happening, they'll do a " were just defending ourselves story for Israelis and then a " we feel sorry for ourselves story for Palestine its pointless reports like this that don't actually fix the problem but make it worse, in a couple of months they'll do a story on the Israeli population that gets rocket attacks. the truth will never get out and there will probably never be peace in the area as both sides would probably want to fight instead of fix the situation, its the bad side of humanity that unfortunately presides over our good side. until their is a full blown war between Israel and the middle east with western involvement and people finally see how stupid all these disagreements are, as it always takes something that's gone to far for mankind to snap out of it and get our act together. only then will we be able to truly solve the problem

Write a comment
Email: *
Your email will not be shared with any third parties or published with your comment.
Nickname: *
Location: *

Title:
*
Comment:
*
Maximum characters 1000

Comment guidelines
Avoid using:
  • Personal attacks
  • Irrelevant comments
  • HTML tags
  • Personal information
  • Offensive language
  • Text in ALL CAPITAL LETTERS
See full comment guidelines
comment guidelines X
Thank you for sharing your opinions with other users of NineMSN. People will find your comments more helpful if you include relevant information and avoid some common pitfalls.
Please note: All reviews and comments submitted are subject to moderation, NineMSN reserves the right to alter and / or remove any content that does not comply with usage guidelines.
What to include in your comment:
  • A title that briefly summarizes the opinion expressed in the comment.
  • Additional comments adding more detail.
  • Comparisons to other similar products, if this is relevant.
  • To create a new paragraph, press the Enter key twice.
What not to include:
  • Information that will quickly go out of date.
  • Comments on other comments or commenters.
  • Language that other users may find offensive.
  • comments of one sentence or less. Provide information to support your opinion.
  • Personal information like your email address or telephone number.
  • HTML coding. Tags like <b> or <i> will not be recognized.
advertisement
Search the site
Search

7.30 pm Sunday
Other ninemsn businesses: iSelect RateCity
© 1997-2009 ninemsn Pty Ltd - All rights reserved